Nigerian televangelist Timothy Omotoso and two female co-accused were acquitted of all charges including rape and human trafficking on Wednesday, ending an eight-year legal saga. Judge Irma Schoeman delivered the verdict at the Eastern Cape High Court at 14:30 local time (12:30 GMT).
Omotoso, alongside Zukiswa Sitho and Lusanda Sulani, faced multiple charges of racketeering, sexual assault, and human trafficking. Prosecutors alleged they groomed young women as young as 14, recruiting victims for abuse across locations in South Africa, Nigeria, and Israel.
Judge Schoeman ruled the state failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt, criticizing prosecutor Nceba Ntelwa’s cross-examination as “poor quality.”
“When the evidence of the accused is not disputed, it is generally taken as correct,” Schoeman stated in her judgment. This lack of effective challenge eliminated the defense’s need to call supporting witnesses.
The televangelist had remained in custody since his April 2017 arrest. Throughout the prolonged proceedings, he made several unsuccessful attempts to have the case dismissed.
Multiple trial delays contributed to witness frustration, with several eventually withdrawing their testimony. Some cited unwillingness to revisit traumatic experiences after moving on with their lives.
“Today’s ruling brings closure to what has become one of South Africa’s most publicized sexual offense cases,” said court spokesperson Anelisa Ngcakani in a statement following the verdict.
The case attracted significant attention in South Africa, where sexual violence remains a widespread concern. Statistics show approximately 115 rapes are reported daily in the country, according to police data.
Despite the serious allegations, Omotoso maintained a dedicated following throughout the trial, with supporters gathering outside the courthouse during key hearings.
Legal experts note the case highlights challenges in prosecuting sexual offense cases, particularly those involving influential figures. Neither prosecution nor defense representatives have indicated whether appeals will be pursued.
The National Prosecuting Authority faces growing criticism over its handling of high-profile cases, with this outcome likely to intensify public debate about judicial effectiveness in sexual violence matters.
